Search

Economic Growth – who pays the price?

Updated: Jul 10, 2021

Written by: Bharti Patel.


The successful exploitation of child labour was vital to Britain’s economic success in the 19th Century”.

In the 19th century it was common and necessary for children of a working-class family in Britain to work in factories and farms. There was less emphasis on education. Some work required the size and agility of children compared to adults and children were cheaper to employ and easier to discipline.


Fast forward to the 21st century. The growing importance of education has led to national and international law giving children everywhere the right to education and governmental protection against all forms of physical or mental violence, injury, abuse, maltreatment or exploitation. Work that is exploitative or hazardous, is mentally, physically, socially or morally dangerous and that interferes or deprives them of schooling, is prohibited under international agreements.


National governments began to introduce laws setting out a legal minimum age at which children could be engaged in light and safe work that will not harm their health or development. Maximum hours are also set for such work so that the child can attend school while contributing to family income. In the UK, children under 16 cannot work during school hours or more than 12 hours in any school week, for example.


In 2015, governments of 191 countries made a collective pledge to take immediate measures to eliminate the worst forms of child labour and eventually end child labour in all its forms. World leaders also promised inclusive, equitable and free quality primary and secondary education and lifelong learning opportunities for every child by 2030 as stated in Goals 4 and 8 of the 17 sustainable Development Goals.

Six years later, 170 million children are engaged in child labour. This is an increase of 8.4 million in the last four years, according to latest report by Unicef and the International Labour Organisation (ILO) Child Labour: Global Estimates 2020, Trends and the Road Forward. Of these 79 million are in hazardous work including mining cobalt, gold and mica or working in the complex supply chains of manufacturing and production of fashion, mobile phones, make up, carpets, toys and jewellery, fruit and vegetables, chocolate, coffee, and cotton. “Fast fashion has engendered a race to the bottom”, said Unicef “pushing companies to find ever cheaper sources of labour that is freely available in many of the countries where textile and garment production takes place” `This work is hazardous to both health and safety. Over half are aged between 5 and 11. More significantly, 72 million children of primary education are not in school. Denied education, they are trapped in a cycle of poverty, exploitation and abuse.


Whilst child labour is most prevalent in low-income countries and emerging economies in the sub-Saharan Africa, Asia and the Pacific, the ILO estimates that 12 million children in upper- or middle-income countries are exploited. In 2013, the Council of Europe’s Commissioner for Human Rights, reported on children working long hours as a consequence of the 2008 economic crisis. In 2019, the UK government’s own data showed 54 per cent of the 4,550 children identified as potential victims of trafficking and modern slavery work in labour sectors, including domestic servitude, hospitality or construction industries and criminal enterprises such as cannabis cultivation.


To this day child labour remains a low cost and high profit business. In a globalised economy, companies are ready to outsource their labour-intensive processes by taking advantage of cheaper labour and accessing cheap raw materials as well as relaxed labour and environmental laws. This is the logic of competing on low costs of production and services. Across the supply chain there is evidence of children working producing goods and services for global consumption and profit. Research by the Ashridge Centre for Business and Sustainability at Hult International Business School and the Ethical Trading Initiative, found 71% of companies in the UK believe there is a likelihood of modern slavery at some stage in their supply chain.


The ILO has estimated an annual profit of US $150.2 billion from the forced labour of men, women and children, with developed Economies and the EU making US$ 46.9 billion profit. Annual profits per victim are highest in the developed economies (US$34,800 per capita), ten times the rate in Africa (US$3,900 per capita)

Child labour, trafficking and forced labour is a violation of a child’s fundamental human rights. To foster a worldwide movement against child labour, The ILO have declared 2021 International Year for the Elimination of Child Labour. Nations are urged to ratify ILO convention 182, which prohibits child labour and to do what is necessary to eliminate worst forms of child labour and end child labour in all its forms by 2025.


Laudable and necessary as these actions are, the reality for many children is far from the protection afforded by Acts of Parliament, international conventions and pledges or ratification of UNCRC and ILO conventions. Exploitation of child labour remains one of the most significant humanitarian issues of the 21st Century. Many children, due to their circumstances of family poverty and lack of access to quality education, represent a source of cheap, compliant labour and are vulnerable to exploitation and abuse.


If global economic success is to be fair and equitable to all countries, global social, economic and environmental systems are required beyond pledges and promises. It requires investment in quality education for children and decent jobs for adults. It requires investment in social protection systems. But most of all, given the economic dominance of multinational corporations (MNCs), it requires companies to rethink their business model and ask themselves the difficult question: “Who is paying the price for our profits?” Laws requiring companies to carry out robust due diligence of environmental and human rights across their supply chains, can help business identify the risks of child labour and take action to prevent exploitation. Introducing a fair, equitable, global corporate tax would ensure MNC’s pay tax on profits in the countries they were generated. The Tax Justice Network advocacy group estimates that a 21% minimum rate would bring in $640bn in underpaid tax.


It is time for the economic success to be built on equitable systems with adequate resources and investments in education, health, and social protection for the world’s most vulnerable people. Children are our future. Let’s not exploit them for economic growth but protect them for economic sustainability.


Bharti Patel is an International Child Rights Advocate and Ambassador for Justice in Fashion

(The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of Justice in Fashion).


Image Source: https://www.ecpat.org.uk/news/uk-offender-simon-harris-sentenced-to-17-years-on-child-sexual-abuse-charges

39 views0 comments